Photo credit: Rolling Stone
These are certainly interesting times as the United States President Donald Trump has sued the BBC for defamation over edited clips of a speech that made it appear he directed supporters to storm the US Capitol. His action has opened an international front in his fight against media coverage he deems untrue or unfair.
CBC News reports that Trump accused Britain’s public broadcaster of defaming him by splicing together parts of a January 6, 2021, speech, including a section where he told supporters to march on the Capitol and another where he said “fight like hell.” It omitted a section in which he called for peaceful protest.
Trump’s lawsuit alleges that the BBC defamed him and violates a Florida law that bars deceptive and unfair trade practices. He is seeking $5 billion US in damages for each of the lawsuit’s two counts.
The BBC has apologized to Trump, admitted an error of judgment and acknowledged that the edit gave the mistaken impression that he had made a direct call for violent action.
But it said there is no legal basis to sue.
Trump, in his lawsuit filed on Monday in Miami federal court, said despite its apology, the BBC “has made no showing of actual remorse for its wrongdoing nor meaningful institutional changes to prevent future journalistic abuses.”
The BBC is funded through a mandatory licence fee on all UK TV viewers, which lawyers there say could make any payout to Trump politically fraught.
A spokesman for Trump’s legal team said in a statement that the BBC “has a long pattern of deceiving its audience in coverage of President Trump, all in service of its own leftist political agenda.”
A BBC spokesman told Reuters earlier on Monday that it had “no further contact from President Trump’s lawyers at this point. Our position remains the same.” The broadcaster did not immediately respond to a request for comment after the lawsuit was filed.
Facing one of the biggest crises in its 103-year history, the BBC has said it has no plans to rebroadcast the documentary on any of its platforms.
The dispute over the clip, featured on the BBC’s Panorama documentary show shortly before the 2024 US presidential election, sparked a public relations crisis for the broadcaster, leading to the resignations of two most senior officials.
Trump’s lawyers say the BBC caused him overwhelming reputational and financial harm.
The documentary drew scrutiny after the leak of a BBC memo by an external standards adviser that raised concerns about how it was edited, part of a wider investigation of political bias at the publicly funded broadcaster.
The documentary was not broadcast in the United States.
Trump may have sued in the United States because defamation claims in Britain must be brought within a year of publication, a window that has closed for the Panorama episode.
To overcome the US Constitution’s legal protection for free speech and the press, Trump will have to prove not only that the edit was false and defamatory but also that the BBC knowingly misled viewers or acted recklessly.
The broadcaster could argue that the documentary was substantially true and its editing decisions did not create a false impression, legal experts said. It could also claim the program did not damage Trump’s reputation.
Other media outlets have settled with Trump, including CBS and ABC, following his lawsuit against them after his comeback win in the November 2024 election.
Trump has filed lawsuits against the New York Times, the Wall Street Journal and a newspaper in Iowa, all of which have denied wrongdoing.
The attack on the US Capitol in January 2021 was aimed at blocking Congress from certifying Joe Biden’s presidential win over Trump in the 2020 US election.
